top of page
Search

Terminating a property sale: beware of registration duties!

Nov 9
3 min read

A property sale can sometimes fall through: the buyer withdraws, the seller refuses to proceed or the parties simply decide to abandon it. But beware: a sale that never completes may still give rise to registration duties. And the bill can be particularly steep, for both buyer and seller!


A couple reviews a document relating to a property sale with a legal professional.

The preliminary sale agreement (and sometimes even an accepted offer) already constitutes a sale


A property sale is generally concluded as soon as the parties agree on the property and the price, without having to wait for the notarial deed to be signed. Even an accepted purchase offer may suffice, depending on its wording and any conditions attached to it.


This date matters because it may be the starting point for the tax time limits, even if a preliminary sale agreement is signed later.


Abandoning a sale can be very expensive!


This is probably the least well-known risk. When a buyer or seller decides not to proceed with a sale that has already been concluded, registration duties may remain payable in full, even if the notarial deed is never signed.


Simply withdrawing is not enough to undo the sale or its tax consequences. Even if the sale is terminated, the tax authorities may claim registration duties if the conditions for avoiding the charge have not been met. They may amount to several tens of thousands of euros.


And the risk does not affect the buyer alone! In all three Regions, where a sale is concluded by a private agreement, the seller may also be pursued for the full amount of the registration duties, even if the sale price has never been received.


In other words, if the buyer does not pay, the seller may have to pay out of their own pocket, subject to any right of recovery against the buyer.


Termination by mutual agreement: a way out of the tax bill


Fortunately, all three Regions provide, subject to certain conditions, for favourable tax treatment where the seller and buyer agree to end the sale.


This mechanism generally allows registration duties to be limited to 10 € for the original sale and 10 € for the agreement terminating it by mutual consent, rather than the usual proportional duties.


In particular, the sale must not yet have been recorded in a notarial deed and termination by mutual agreement must take place within one year of the original agreement, subject in particular to the specific rules concerning suspensive conditions.


The parties must also comply with the registration formalities, which differ according to the Region concerned.


Beware: the one-year period does not give any additional time to complete the tax formalities or pay the duties. It allows favourable tax treatment to apply, subject to certain conditions, when the sale ends. Depending on the circumstances, proportional duties may be avoided or, if already paid, may be the subject of a refund claim.


What if the parties cannot agree?


Where termination by mutual agreement is impossible, it may be necessary to ask the court to terminate the sale, particularly if one party fails to fulfil their obligations.


Here too, the one-year tax time limit is decisive: to qualify for favourable refund treatment, court proceedings seeking termination must generally be brought within one year of the agreement. It is the date proceedings are brought that matters, not the date of the judgment.


Other mechanisms, including the judicial annulment of the sale, are subject to different rules.


What if the duties have already been paid?


Regional legislation also allows, subject to certain conditions, a refund of registration duties already paid.


The time limit for claiming a refund is generally two years in Wallonia and Brussels, compared with five years in Flanders, calculated from different starting points. This must not be confused with the one-year period mentioned above.


Lastly, where there is a genuine suspensive condition, such as obtaining a loan, its non-fulfilment may prevent proportional duties from becoming due. If the condition is fulfilled, that date may also change the starting point of the tax time limits.


Conclusion


When a property sale goes wrong, it is therefore not enough to consider how to end it legally. The tax consequences must also be anticipated.


A sale that never completes can still result in a substantial tax debt, for which both the buyer and the seller may be held liable.


When it comes to property, inaction can be expensive!


This article is intended for information purposes and does not constitute legal advice. For any specific question, you are advised to consult a legal professional.


Mr Raffaele Petrullo, lawyer admitted to the Brussels and Luxembourg Bars (www.astralis-law.be – 02 705 57 47 – info@astralis-law.be).


 
 
 

Comments


Astralis Law

bottom of page